Title Theory
State | Title Theory↓ | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alaska | Title | ||
| Arizona | Title | ||
| Colorado | Title | ||
| District of Columbia | Title | ||
| Georgia | Title | ||
| Idaho | Title | ||
| Mississippi | Title | ||
| Missouri | Title | ||
| Nebraska | Title | ||
| Nevada | Title | ||
| North Carolina | Title | ||
| Oregon | Title | ||
| South Dakota | Title | ||
| Tennessee | Title | ||
| Texas | Title | ||
| Utah | Title | Debatable. Utah mortgage laws include conflicting statutes on lien theory. | |
| Virginia | Title | ||
| Washington | Title | ||
| West Virginia | Title | ||
| Wyoming | Title | ||
| Arkansas | Lien | ||
| Connecticut | Lien | ||
| Delaware | Lien | ||
| Florida | Lien | ||
| Illinois | Lien | ||
| Indiana | Lien | ||
| Iowa | Lien | ||
| Kansas | Lien | ||
| Kentucky | Lien | ||
| Louisiana | Lien | ||
| Maine | Lien | ||
| New Jersey | Lien | ||
| New Mexico | Lien | ||
| New York | Lien | ||
| North Dakota | Lien | ||
| Ohio | Lien | ||
| Pennsylvania | Lien | ||
| South Carolina | Lien | ||
| Wisconsin | Lien | ||
| Alabama | Intermediary | ||
| Hawaii | Intermediary | ||
| Maryland | Intermediary | ||
| Massachusetts | Intermediary | ||
| Michigan | Intermediary | ||
| Minnesota | Intermediary | ||
| Montana | Intermediary | ||
| New Hampshire | Intermediary | ||
| Oklahoma | Intermediary | ||
| Rhode Island | Intermediary | ||
| Vermont | Intermediary | ||
| California | Debated | Although California is considered a title state by many sources, Section 5 of the California Department of Real Estate's reference book states "It is settled law that California is a 'lien' and not a 'legal title' theory state when imposing encumbrances/liens against the title of real property." |
In title theory states, the lender holds legal title to the property until the mortgage is fully repaid. While the borrower retains the right to occupy and use the property, the lender’s ownership interest allows for a more streamlined foreclosure process in the event of default, often without court involvement.
These states include Alaska, Arizona, Colorado, District of Columbia, Georgia, Idaho, Mississippi, Missouri, Nebraska, Nevada, North Carolina, Oregon, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, and Wyoming.
In lien theory states, the borrower holds legal title to the property while the lender retains a lien as security for the loan. Foreclosure in these states typically requires a judicial process, which can add time and complexity if the borrower defaults.
States in this category include Arkansas, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Dakota, Ohio, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, and Wisconsin.
Intermediary theory states combine elements of both title and lien theory. In these states, the borrower holds title under normal conditions, but the lender may take title upon default, allowing for a foreclosure process that can be more streamlined than in lien theory states.
Currently, intermediary theory states are Alabama, Hawaii, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Montana, New Hampshire, Oklahoma, Rhode Island, and Vermont.
The distinction among title, lien, and intermediary theory primarily affects who holds legal title during the life of the loan and how foreclosure is handled if the borrower defaults. Title theory states typically allow non-judicial foreclosure, making the process faster and more administrative. Lien theory states usually require judicial foreclosure, which involves court proceedings and can take longer. Intermediary theory states fall between the two, with borrowers holding title initially but lenders gaining additional rights in the event of default.